Catalina Island Fishing Holidays

Very clean honestly I have amazing experience w my family

clean room, staff , shop at the hotel, close to the beach

I had to cancel 2 nights of a 4 night reservation and they were very gracious and returned 2 nights charges.

This hotel was very well maintained and the staff were great! I would recommend this property for a stay in the LA area.

Avery nice place to stay

Loved the rooftop pool, valet parking people were great, friendly staff at the hotel!!

Great location and friendly staff.

The Surf and Sand: Stunning Location, Disappointing Service The Surf and Sand's oceanfront location is genuinely spectacular—the kind of view that justifies five-star pricing. Unfortunately, the service quality falls far short of the property's premium positioning. Dining Issues: Our concierge recommended Splashes despite acknowledging recent reconstruction concerns, claiming they'd received no complaints. The reality was a severely limited menu with overpriced, overly rich dishes that didn't justify the cost. When we expressed concerns, no alternative dining options were suggested. Cancelled Services: Multiple advertised amenities failed to materialize. Morning yoga and other scheduled activities were cancelled without advance notice. Most frustratingly, a spa facial appointment booked a month in advance was cancelled when the aesthetician simply didn't show up. Billing Problems: Despite prepaying for our room, the hotel placed a $1,300 hold on our card for "incidentals"—an unusually high amount for a one-night stay. Additionally, the spa charged $148 for the cancelled facial service, and spa staff couldn't locate any record of the charge when we inquired. Bottom Line: While the oceanfront setting is undeniably beautiful, the property's operational issues—from unreliable service to questionable billing practices—don't support its five-star reputation. The location alone isn't enough to justify the premium pricing when basic hospitality standards aren't met.

Lovely well appointed room, good location and facilities

clean room, staff , shop at the hotel, close to the beach

I had to cancel 2 nights of a 4 night reservation and they were very gracious and returned 2 nights charges.