City Island Apart Hotels

"I stay here every time I’m in the city. The people are so lovely & the rooms are always clean."

"The room was very clean. A bit smaller than I expected from the online photos. Our shower enclosure was leaking so we had to put down towels every time we showered. Otherwise it was a pretty decent stay. "

"This hotel is worth it for the included breakfast alone - I have never seen such an all encompassing hotel breakfast. Also, no street noise while trying to sleep, which is always a plus in NYC. Broadway shows were literally right outside our hotel, so perfect location if that is part of your trip."

"The hotel was in a great location. It was clean, the staff was accommodating, and it felt safe. "

"I did not have internet all the time! That was unfair! I have paid too much for hotel"

"Room was filthy! Property needs serious updating and the cleanliness of this hotel is extremely poor."

"Breakfast was literally not edible. They had leather disks they called sausage that were not edible. They had hashbrowns that were freezer burned and not edible. Never served bacon or other options. It was horrible. "

"I really only needed the room for the overnight portion, so it was nice to arrive fairly late and the room was just as needed - clean, quiet, and ready to go. Bed was comfortable, bathroom had all I needed. Location couldn’t be better- 30 seconds from Times Square. No breakfast in hotel but a handy bakery downstairs with coffee and all sorts of nice treats. My second stay here and I would select again in a heartbeat. "

"Great location!"