Plum Island Apart Hotels

"Location and also the hotel vibe "

"Clean room, heart of New York "

"No room service, broken elevators, dirty carpets in hallway, freezing cold showers due to alleged pipe burst, tub was dirty, paper thin walls, concierge doesn’t respond to text or calls when reaching out, and someone was doing bdsm in the hallway. Never, ever again!!!"

"dont stay there"

"Clean, comfortable and close to many attractions "

"Best location! Also plus that they let us check in early"

"Everything was wonderful "

"Awesome location, great vibe and friendly staff, service at restaurant was somewhat disorganized."

"Absolutely beautiful room, friendly staff, and having a coffee shop downstairs was so nice. I felt like for the amount of space and the very ideal location, the price was well worth it. My husband was amazed at how great the view was. We got in 5 hours before checkin. I texted to ask if we could drop off our bags and they responded quickly that we could. We were pleasantly surprised to know that our room was ready when we got there at noon that we could go straight to our room. I’d saw for cons: we were on the 14th floor and could pretty clearly hear road noise (duh it’s NYC) but I do travel with a small white noise machine and it cleared everything out. Also the room did run a little warm. I wasn’t uncomfortable due to it still being cold out, but I would worry about the temp if it were warmer outside. This is likely also due to the room being almost solid windows and having a lot of light exposure. Overall I’d stay again for the view. "