Top Hotels Near South Beach in Fishers Island from AU$138

"The staff were wonderful, including the manager, who calmly and kindly helped us through a booking issue with Expedia in that we only had one room for the stay, while we had booked two through Expedia. The staff made an extra effort to make Christmas morning special, by dressing up in holiday jumpers and the buffet included luscious strawberries, whipped cream and chocolate chips fashioned into adorable santas. A plus for the staff. The hotel was beautifully decorated in all public areas and they made a special effort to decorate for the holidays inside and out. The pool areas was nice but a tad chilly. Gym was clean and workable.Towels, water and seating was abundant in both. The hotel was very clean as were our rooms. We had adjoining doubles, which was convenient for our family. We loved the public spaces by the gas fireplace and enjoyed the very cool outdoor atrium with gas warming fires under lights and the open sky. The beds were extremely firm, which was not great for our backs. This was the biggest drawback. The location is fantastic. We walked to the Aquarium and Olde Mistick VIllage, which is truly a fantastic spot for specialty shops, dining and movie theater. We had a short drive to the Seaport, which would have been walkable if it weren't 26 degrees with a windchill factor that brought us down into almost the single digits. What a great little Christmas vacation we had in Mystic, in large part thanks to the Mystic Hilton. "

"Clean beautiful room. Staff was very friendly. Definitely recommend!"

"This is an amazing property and a fantastic location. When I first walked in, I was so happy that I chose to say here. It was beautiful , clean and so spacious ! I chose this home to have my pre-Christmas get together for my family. My kids/grandchildren live in different states and this location was in the middle of all of us. It was so perfect and exactly what I was looking for. The surrounding areas were so pretty as well and we spent a special night at Old Mistick Village. It was decorated so beautifully with lights and shops all around. I also was able to catch an awesome sunrise one morning from the property . It also snowed one of the days there, which made it even more magical!Thank you, David, for renting your beautiful home to me. It could not have been a more perfect stay!"

"Amazing place to stay ! "

"Gorgeous house, terrific location. Everything in the home was thoughtfully designed. We loved our stay. "

"The location was so peaceful and beautiful! We were a quick drive into Mystic. Comfy beds, plenty of towels, everything we needed and more. Parking was easy and communication prior to check in was outstanding. We can’t wait to stay again soon! Thank you for a perfect coastal weekend. "

"Place was fabulous. Host was very responsive. Everything was in walking distance. House is in a terrific location Getting into house and leaving was simple. Love to go back "