Holiday Homes in Lower Matecumbe Key

"This place was far below expectations! Dozens of unsupervised children running around at all hours of the night screaming, party music every night until 2:30am, people banging on the room door all night for fun, shower didn’t drain and left you in 4” of gross water in just a few minutes, room was outdated, had to unplug the tv because it turned itself off and on all night long (never worked properly), no fan in the room or bathroom, and worst of all… we watched a woman proposition a couple in the parking lot for a threesome which later turned out to be the hotel’s cleaning lady. We would have stayed somewhere else but were stuck in the area for a wedding and had nowhere else available. Would not recommend!! "

"Pros: easy parking, ocean view, spacious living area, beach and pool access Cons: interior of unit was kind of shabby with stains on couch arm, worn out towels, grunge on bathroom sink faucet, outdated tub"

"Beautiful property and the beach is nice, calm, and quiet. The made to order breakfasts every morning were absolutely amazing and delicious! My only complaint was that we explored Islamorada and did adventures during the day off the property. When we came back after dinnertime, we wanted to use some of the amenities such as fishing or having a drink from the bar and everything closed early (4:00-7:00 it was closed by). Would've been nice to have those things open till dark. "

"Wonderful place! Beautiful beach and the staff were awesome! "

"Very nice room in the pool villa, property was nice but not impressive. Front desk lady was unfriendly. Could have been better with friendlier staff. "

"We stayed in the King Oceanfront Suite and it was perfect. Clean, modern, nice big balcony. The grounds were well kept and there were plenty of water sports equipment for use. The breakfast is not very plentiful or varied but not a reason to keep me from staying here! I would definitely recommend it and will stay here again. There’s also a food truck on the grounds with excellent food!"

"Beautiful location with great rooms, awesome friendly service and nice resort amenties like complementary cooked to order breakfast and kayak use. Only complaint is the room door stuck and needed some attention. Also, pool hours could have been longer. "

"Room was not ready until 6pm and was dirty "

"My husband and I stayed here for our baby moon, and we honestly couldn’t recommend this place more! After doing a painful amount of research, it was difficult to decide between this resort and a few other ones we found, but I am so glad we went with The Islander. The grounds are beautiful, the staff is lovely, and the setup of the resort is all you could hope for! We truly forgot we were still in the U.S. and not on a tropical island. We also lucked out with our room location, being right near the pool, so we didn’t have to get out there early to “reserve” chairs, didn’t have to go far to use the bathroom, etc. It’s a family-friendly resort, but it’s not like it’s impossible for adults without children to relax. I’d recommend The Islander to anyone looking to stay in Islamorada."