Cheap flights from Indianapolis to Coney Island

View AU$137 flight on Tue, 2 Sep. 2025Opens in a new window

Popular airlines from Indianapolis to Coney Island

  • Plan, book, fly with confidence

  • trending down icon

    Be in the know

    Get alerts if flight prices drop or rise*
  • bex rewards loyalty icon

    Book smarter

    Save up to 35% on select hotels after you book a flight*
  • payments icon

    Earn twice

    Earn your airline miles on top of our rewards
    Sign in

Cheap Flights from Indianapolis (IND) to Coney Island (LGA)

Prices were available within the past 7 days for one-way flights and round trip tickets for the period specified. Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms apply.

Delta
Tue, 30 Sep. - Tue, 7 Oct.
IND
Indianapolis
JFK
New York
AU$212 Return, found 11 hours ago
AU$212
Return
found 11 hours ago
Select Delta flight, departing Tue, 30 Sep. from Indianapolis to New York, returning Tue, 7 Oct., priced at AU$212 found 11 hours ago
American Airlines
Sat, 6 Sep. - Sat, 13 Sep.
IND
Indianapolis
JFK
New York
AU$214 Return, found 4 days ago
AU$214
Return
found 4 days ago
Select American Airlines flight, departing Sat, 6 Sep. from Indianapolis to New York, returning Sat, 13 Sep., priced at AU$214 found 4 days ago
Delta
Sat, 6 Sep. - Sat, 13 Sep.
IND
Indianapolis
LGA
New York
AU$229 Return, found 4 days ago
AU$229
Return
found 4 days ago
Select Delta flight, departing Sat, 6 Sep. from Indianapolis to New York, returning Sat, 13 Sep., priced at AU$229 found 4 days ago
Delta
Sat, 6 Sep. - Sat, 13 Sep.
IND
Indianapolis
JFK
New York
AU$229 Return, found 4 days ago
AU$229
Return
found 4 days ago
Select Delta flight, departing Sat, 6 Sep. from Indianapolis to New York, returning Sat, 13 Sep., priced at AU$229 found 4 days ago
United
Sat, 6 Sep. - Sat, 13 Sep.
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
New York
AU$322 Return, found 4 days ago
AU$322
Return
found 4 days ago
Select United flight, departing Sat, 6 Sep. from Indianapolis to New York, returning Sat, 13 Sep., priced at AU$322 found 4 days ago
Alaska Airlines
Thu, 11 Sep. - Thu, 25 Sep.
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
New York
AU$910 Return, found 1 day ago
AU$910
Return
found 1 day ago
Select Alaska Airlines flight, departing Thu, 11 Sep. from Indianapolis to New York, returning Thu, 25 Sep., priced at AU$910 found 1 day ago

Find the cheapest month to fly from Indianapolis (IND) to New York (JFK)

September is typically the cheapest month to fly

From AU$213 - AU$324 per traveller.

Graph displaying average flight prices per month

*Available to Expedia members.