Search Farmstay in Shelter Island

"The condition of the hotel was shocking. Bugs is the only word I need to say. I stay in hotels for work constantly and never complain. But this was unbelievable, I had spiders , and other bugs all over the room."

"Clean room"

"Very nice place. Great location."

"If you can look beyond the immediate exterior and sense of disrepair (it's not...), then you can enjoy the stay here. While there is no swimming pool, the property is well positioned to the coast and local beaches. They were doing some road construction immediately outside the property and on the route to the shore roads, this should be wrapped up fairly quickly. Restaurants were close enough to walk to, we recommend Luigi's for their calamari, whether it be for seafood or pizza. There is even a store selling fresh produce right down the street. Enjoyed our stay and would definitely stay here again in the future if the opportunity presents itself."

"Nice room and view "

"Had a great stay here! Nice location just off the beach, conveniently in the middle of town. The room was spotless (it was in the first week or two of the season) on the small side but has everything you need including a tiny kitchen."

"Great for dogs - huge fenced yard"

"We made our reservation paid the bill we got to the hotel they told us you have to pay $29 a night to park your car in the hotel parking lot. WE WERE NEVER INFORMED OF THIS!! I have my reservation to prove it!!!"

"Stellar staff who made us feel most welcome. Loved the diversity of the team. Unforgettable scenery and experiences. We will definitely come back!"