Historic Hotels & Resorts in San Juan Island

"Pet friendly. Good climate control. Although a shower head was installed, there was no valve to divert water above the tub basin faucet. Thus, no shower. The bathroom sink faucet baseplate moved across the sink area. Dooming disaster. Needs caulking. Faceplates surrounding light switches and electrical outs need to be cleaned with disinfectant Good landscaping maintenance. Beautiful gardens spread throughout the super large property "

"★★★★★ A Cozy, Welcoming Stay at Tucker House We stayed one night in a cottage at the Tucker House with our dog and absolutely loved it. The location was easy to find and perfect for exploring Friday Harbor. Our cottage felt warm, welcoming, and wonderfully cozy from the moment we arrived. We were greeted with delicious cookies and a homemade treat for our dog — who’s usually a picky eater but devoured it instantly! The thoughtful touches really made us feel at home. The split doors were a charming feature — we loved opening the top half to let in the fresh sea air while relaxing by the fireplace. The temperature was perfect, and the whole space felt peaceful and comfortable. Breakfast was delivered right to our door the next morning and was absolutely delicious. We only stayed one night, but it was such a lovely experience — we’d happily come back and highly recommend this super cozy and comfortable inn."

"We had a Hourbor View in the Quarrymen. The room was beautiful. The staff were friendly. This was an anniversary stay. The dinner at McMillan's was fabulous. A quaint fairytale town. Highly recommend."

"Welcoming people, clean and safe. Close to downtown. Thanks for having a shower!"

"Rooms are outdated in 90s decor, but if you don't care about that, everything else is great. Rooms are cozy and warm with gas fireplace and peaceful patios. Nice to have a kitchen and separate bedrooms. Location is fantastic and staff were friendly."

"Breakfast was good, and liked being able to get coffee or tea when I liked. Staff were absolutely exceptional!! So friendly, from check in, breakfast staff, and housekeepers. Parking was super easy and right by my room."

"For years we have considered Auld Inn Inn our “home away from home” when visiting our son and family in Oak Harbor. The clean, comfortable rooms and friendly, courteous staff help make it a very pleasant, convenient headquarters on holidays, b"

"Never really saw the staff, but didn't need them. "

"I think we booked a high end room as it was pricy but had a jetted tub, and fireplace in the room. The location was great as we could walk everywhere except the National Park. "