Garvald Hotels, Edinburgh

"Bistro food was only okay on this occasion."

"We stayed two nights with another 4 members of my family. Hotel had recently changed hands. It was a lovely quiet country inn in a small village with plenty of parking. Good pulic room for sitting with family and generally the hotel was very individual. Room had everything we needed including a bath with good hanging space.The manager was very hands on and a pleasant man. The lady doing the breakfast couldn't have done more and everything was freshly cooked and brought to the table. Excellent choice of food for breakfast. We didn't eat in the evening as we were visiting family but menu had a good selection. Had a problem with hot water in bath and sink to which the Manager was very attentive in trying to sort. Had a village shop but not much else but that was what we wanted. Lovely overall stay and definitely would return "

"Fantastic"

"Exceptional experience from first arrival and greetings to cheak out lovely staff and food shame I can't give more than 5* room was very good also bed slightly hard but can't complain thankyou to all the staff"

"Melville Castle was amazing lovely atmosphere for a relaxing weekend beautiful scenery and surrounding area . Staff were excellent x"

"Staff Milan is very nice guy and help whenever possible. Big thanks to him."

"Hotel was good tv channels a bit fuzzy "

"Gorgeous castle close to Edinburgh! So far the main areas are renovated and they are stunning. The aesthetic blends castle feel (gold mirrors, beautiful wooden buttresses, textured wallpaper) with fabulous modern touches (lighting and tiling). We stayed in suite 27 and it had luxurious touches throughout (copper bathtub, double headed shower, new tiling, beautiful new bed) mixed with remnants of the castle feel (tapestry headboard and ancient well (secured) . The bar was classy and had a wide array of wine and full bar on display. The dining room was gorgeous and we had a phenomenal dinner and breakfast. The library is a great spot to read and has a hidden whiskey room. Ask for the castle tour! So glad we stayed here!"

"Breakfast was average Dinner was disappointing "