Top Hotels Near Shelter Island Country Club in Shelter Island Heights from AU$330

"Everything exceeded all expectations. Excellence is a not strong enough description. "

"Clean hotel , comfortable room, beautiful views, quiet place, EZ access to the beach. Coming back for summer"

"Spacious, well appointed rooms. Great location. The complimentary breakfast was cozy (nothing fancy but gets the job done). We stayed for three nights with a small dog in tow. The only surprise was that parking was not free ($29 per night) but there was plenty of free street parking available nearby."

"Thank you, Patrick, for sharing your magical home with us. After a long winter, our week at the Chicken Coop felt truly restorative. The space is very clean, well-appointed, comfortable, and sits on gorgeous property. We loved all the whimsical details!We loved the constant connection to nature—“bird TV” from the bedroom window, osprey flybys, even the occasional late-night wildlife drama. It was such a gift to experience it all so closely.We’re also grateful for your generosity in sharing your knowledge of Greenport and its maritime culture.We leave with wonderful memories and look forward to returning."

"My girlfriend and I stayed in April and it was amazing stay. Rooms are outstanding, one of the best rooms we ever stayed, and location was stunning. Beautiful marina, great waterfront views from the property. It was so quiet and relaxing. We went to Greenport for dinners. 10$ Breakfast cards were provided by hotel for Stone Street eatery and it was nice delicious meal. My girlfriend is from Milan, Italy and this was her first time in North Fork and she absolutely loved it thanks to The Shoals. "

"This is my third time at the Cliffside, and as always it was a lovely space that was great value for money. The only reason I didn’t give it five stars was that the heat was wildly inconsistent: in the small bedroom it was very hot, and the kitchen/living room, cool, and in the master bedroom, frigid. Otherwise, great. "

"Tara was wonderful and helpful at check-in, the cleaning staff was so nice and thorough, and the food at Nookies and the Boathouse were both amazing!! "

"amazing stay! "

"One staff member was there to check us in. He was helpful in bringing our bags to our room. He also suggested several restaurants for us to try."