Top Hotels Near Shelter Island Whale's Tail in Shelter Island from AU$177

"Great check in experience. Very nice room"

"Great stay, will definitely go again"

"absolutely charming and totally bats above its weight. splurge for the bungalow!"

"Wonderful stay in a quaint hotel..The small town was amazing and had such cozy welcoming atmosphere! "

"This place is a perfect oasis in an already special environment. The host was wonderful and thoughtful. The cottage was magical and had everything to offer that one could want. "

"Great room with amazing views! Staff was fantastic and the food was great too"

"Outstanding on all levels.. Hospitality and food top notch."

"Not applicable "

"The House on Chase Creek is absolutely amazing! My husband and I are celebrating our 20th anniversary and I’ve been telling him about Shelter Island literally for almost 40 years. Well we finally made it and the trip, the home, the welcoming of my dog, was all so just so welcoming and nice. Bill, the proprietor, took great care to answer any questions and tell us about the Island. Then we enter the most immaculate room, as clean as the ritz! I mean it…I broke a glass by my nightstand and had to move the stand to clean up the glass; when I say not one speck of dust, not one fuzz bunny, so clean you could eat off the floor, even under the bed!! We enjoyed our stay so much we extended our trip and Bill, was extremely helpful, and welcomed us to stay longer! We can’t wait to go back, and we are going to try and make it an annual event. Thank you Bill for all your kindness and see you soon!!! MA and Erich Schmalhorst. PS. The bed AMAZING, sleep so peaceful, I can’t express how wonderful this place is to stay in. I almost want to erase this review because I don’t want to let the “cat out of the bag”!"