Search Island of Venice Villa Accommodation

"Clean room, close proximity to the beach and shopping district. Complimentary beach chairs and the patio is relaxing"

"The decor was absolutely fabulous, friendly staff, new love in Sarasota"

"The beauty of the “resort” is its close proximity to the wonderful Siesta Key beach. I use quotations because it’s really just shelter and a pool, although a nice pool. The staff members were very nice and helpful but couldn’t do much for us in upgrading our room as they claim they never got our requests from the 3rd-party broker. "

"The room was pristine, well equipped and spacious. Staff were all friendly and took time to ask where we were from and were super helpful. Breakfast was limited but what was on offer was excellent. We stopped at this hotel for a week in 2025 and were blown away by the quality of this hotel. As we were visiting Sarasota for a couple of days in 2026 we had no hesitation in booking the Carlisle again."

"Breakfast was good, but the property needs a good handyman bathroom door was broken and the wall needs to be fixed and painted."

"Love this place!! Staff was awesome, the grounds are well maintained and the room exceeded our expectations. Cute decor and was really quiet, parking was a breeze. Had everything we needed and it is right across the street from the beach, literally RIGHT across the street. It is about a half mile walk to the downtown area for restaurants and shopping, but there is a quick hamburger/hotdog place in the same block that was convenient for a quick bite (really good fries). If you are looking to shark tooth hunt, they have scoops and floating sifters available. I would not hesitate to stay here again."

"I liked the inclusive breakfast. Room (mostly bathroom) was not throughly clean. Couldn’t access my hotel room past a certain hour and the staff mentioned that sometimes there are issues with the keys not opening, which I found it frustrating."

"Great location on beach with convenient lounge chairs and umbrellas. Kids also loved the new pool. Many restaurants within walking distance but they get crowded. Our 2nd visit there and will be back in future."

"The room was very clean and bed is comfortable. I would recommend this hotel "