Top Hotels Near Theater of the Sea in Islamorada from AU$274

"The breakfast had issues. because of an electrical issue the guests could not get water any other juice from the machine. I like a liquid with your very good omlettes.Jazmin was very helpful in checking in and out/MY reason for staying at your resort is to fish and I did well late afternoon/"

"The room was more spacious than we expected! Nicely decorated there were a few tiles in the bathroom that were broken but still very nice and didn’t cause any problems. Great beach area for sitting and enjoying the evenings. The bed was comfortable but did squeak. And the free breakfast was very lacking even for a free breakfast. Staff was very friendly and helpful! Would stay here again! "

"The staff here are great. Crystal at the front desk was more than helpful with questions about exploring the area and helping with anything we needed during our stay. The pool is nice and the view of the ocean is great. The rooms are dated but keep very clean. "

"5 Star Stay!Everything from booking to checking out went smoothly, and all communications with the host were timely. This property is absolutely gorgeous, and even better than the listing suggests. The kitchen was well stocked with appliances, dishes, coffeemakers (both regular and a Keurig) and cookware. There were enough paper products and items like soap and dish detergent to get us through the week. The location within Angler's Reef is perfect...only a few steps to the beach and pool, and the front porch offers a beautiful view overlooking the marina and beyond. The kayaks and paddle boards that are available to guests were a wonderful bonus, and we used them often. We did not make use of the boat slip this visit, but it was fun to walk down in the evening to see what the fishermen were bringing in. The beds were so comfortable, and our family of 5 had plenty of room to spread out into their own space. Overall, a perfect week, and we can't wait to visit again! "

"The rooms we were in were definitely tired with thin walls. You could hear everything in the room next door. The golf course lodging probably needs to be torn down and rebuilt. The property/location was great and the staff were super friendly. "

"Quiet, great staff, plenty to do. "

"Absolutely beautiful townhome - we truly loved our stay. You can tell so much care went into every detail, and everything felt spotless and welcoming from the moment we walked in. The views are incredible and made it even more special.Rebecca was wonderful - so kind, responsive, and genuinely thoughtful, which made the whole experience feel easy and personal.Our only “complaint” is that now we’re seriously considering upgrading our TV at home after this stay! We’re already looking forward to coming back."

"Food was excellent and the staff was delightful. Very accommodating"

"Pool staff great. Too windy to do beach activities our trip unfortunately. Hotel room was great. Beautiful views. Check in was an unfortunate process. We were hoping for an early check in, instead didn’t get checked in till after our guaranteed 4PM."