Top Hotels Near Theater of the Sea in Islamorada from AU$271

"The king suite with ocean view was fantastic. The resort is in good shape with plenty of space to lounge, activities and includes nice breakfast options. Also close to many bars and restaurants. "

"We had a wonderfull time. Everyone was very attentive and helpful."

"Great place to stay! The staff were wonderful! Quiet, peaceful, and enjoyable stay! Rooms were spacious and clean! "

" Todo ok"

"The staff was personable, great location, having the bicycles and kayaks were a great touch"

"Very clean and updated rooms. Outside bar area and food awesome. Very friendly staff. You would drive past OV if just looked at it from the A1A. Take the time and go around back. "

"Our host thought of everything; communication was great- early checkin was provided as well. The location near sandbar, Publix, The Village shops, bait shop, many restaurants was awesome! The condo was spotless, towels provided, paddleboards, games, books etc. The view of this particular condo was worth the upgrade. Lattes were a hit as well! All good things-"

"Host is responsive and informative. Resort is spectacular... Pristine grounds. Beautiful pool and beach is perfect for sunrise and sunset. Lots of kayaks and paddle boards to use. Home is clean and well stocked. This was our third time at anglers reef and it never disapoints"

"Perfect accommodations! I would give more than 5 stars if I could!We travel a lot as a family (2 adults and 2 teens) and have stayed in many places. This is one we will be talking about for many years to come!!!Hosts were amazing with communication, very clear instructions and quick to respond; also sending messages to check in to make sure we didn’t need anything. Private, safe, beautiful inside and out, perfectly decorated and appointed, clean and comfortable, everything you could ever ask for in a stay! Highlights:Very comfortable bedsBoat slip with fish cleaning station and hose to clean the boatPool was warm(heated doesn’t always mean warm at rentals)House has everythingWasher and dryer brand new and work very well making laundry at the end of the day easyCleanBeautifulThank you for making this vacation so wonderful! We will definitely be back!"