Historic Hotels & Resorts in St Kilda West from AU$179

"Room was clean and breakfast was fantastic "

"The standout are the staff and Collins place breakfast. Rooms were loud as you could hear others in their rooms and bathrooms. Very warm room and aircon don’t seem to work. Could hear lifts move up and down despite being a few rooms away. Bed was comfortable."

"Beautiful hotel. Friendly staff."

"Front counter staff at arrival (2pm) seemed tired and uninterested and the smell of dog urine and visible signs on the entrance steps weren’t pleasant However the inside of the hotel was clean, fresh and easy to navigate Housekeeping was 5 star-our beds were comfy-always important! we stayed 2 nights price was reasonable if you are a wheelchair user I would recommend the hotel The early morning staff at checkout gave away smiles for free "

"Ok"

"The room is old and smells like old wet furniture. I must I still did not mind as we were out most of the times and staff at reception were really good and helpful. However, on our last day, we spotted a rat coming out near the fridge in the midnight, this was spotted by my partner and she was extremely scared and disgusted, as we had our clothes placed in the cabinet near the fridge. We did not go to report immediately as it was too late and we were very tired and were checking out at 11 in the morning. I have reported this to the reception while checking out, he was kind enough to acknowledge my concern and even provide a carpark waiver, however, I feel this incident has made us feel so disgusted and it shouldn’t happen on a holiday."

"Room wasn’t properly cleaned. Yellow stains on all quilts. Shower water don’t drain well. Broken toilet flush button. Reported to the receptionist as well. "

"Nice hotel. Getting a little dated, can be a bit of a maze. Staff are really good and the area is hard to beat (despite the hills)."

"I think I paid a demand pricing premium but this hotel did not feel like it was worth the price. It felt extremely budget. It was quite noisy and the aircon was ancient and loud. I think at a discount it would be fine, but at a premium it felt very shabby indeed. If you're going to upcharge in the up season at least dust the rooms!"