Search Sheffield Island hotels

"Clean room, great staff. We love every visit we have here!"

"Check-in was very simple. Staff was very friendly. Room and lobby area were very clean. Bed was comfortable. Outside of the property was well taken care and area felt very safe. Perfect location to I-95 with plenty of gas stations/food nearby. Will be back."

"I love historic properties, and this one is stellar! I was delighted to see all the fireplaces, woodwork, columns. Thoughtful restoration that makes sense. Loved everything about this property!"

"Walls were thin, could hear fighting/snoring/dog barking in other rooms, outdoor traffic. Breakfast was very good, one of the few highlights. Bed saggy. Key cards were incorrectly deactivated TWICE during a 5-night stay, necessitating extra trips to the Front Desk so we could get into our room. Housekeeping is NOT daily, as the hotel description says on Hotels.com; it was performed only after 3 nights (that seems like a rather long interval), and then it was incomplete (e.g., ice bucket was not emptied). While one could request needed items via a door hanger between housekeeping visits, we did not receive the items we specified. Bathroom sink was nearly clogged, emptied extremely slowly. BEWARE: there is a $15/nt. parking fee + tax that is not included in the Hotels.com pricing, although it is listed in the "At A Glance" section. "

"Although the facility appears fairly new, the shower water pressure was so poor. After reporting and maintenance repairing, the pressure was worse. Almost impossible to shower. We spent 2 nights and were told there is no daily housekeeping after our first day. "

"Nice room with beach and ocean view. Room was perfect."

"Had a great visit -will be back"

"This is an excellent value, just up the road from Cumberland Island ferry. It’s an older property but clean and neat. Even a very nice breakfast, and a busy, friendly and efficient attendant. Well done! "

"This is a totally charming hotel which is truly a bed and breakfast antique vibe. It is an old historic i nfull of rustic charm, a clean comfortable roo. With aur cinditioning in a prime downtown location. Being historic, it is "low tech" our bathroom facilities while functional wer unconventional. The claw foot tub doubling as a shower in the room. Overall if you are looking for modern amenities this is not for you but if you embrace a deep breath of fresh air, homey staff, a lovely breakfast with a beautiful courtyard and a cozy step back in time, it is absolutely delightful!!! We loved it!"