Close to Mystic Downtown Marina, Historic Waterfront School House provides amenities, such as a garden and laundry facilities. Guests can connect to in-room WiFi.
Reviews
9.89.8 out of 10
Exceptional
Popular amenities
Kitchen
Washing machine
Dryer
Pet-friendly
Air-conditioning
Outdoor space
Add dates for prices
About this property
Historic Waterfront School House
Escape to a historic 1857 schoolhouse cottage on the Mystic River. This unique 1-bed, 1-bath waterfront retreat is perfect for couples or solo travelers. Enjoy stunning views of the Mystic Drawbridge and Seaport from your private patio. Just a 2-block walk to historic Downtown Mystic, this charming space combines authentic history with modern comfort for an unforgettable stay. We are pet friendly and have a Pack n Play and High Chair.
The Space Step back in time at this thoughtfully relocated and transformed 1857 schoolhouse, now a peaceful 1-bedroom, 1-bath cottage on the Mystic River. Perfect for couples or solo travelers, this retreat combines authentic historic charm with modern comforts for a truly unique waterfront stay.
The cottage features: * A cozy family room with a 55-inch HDTV with streaming services. * A dedicated workspace for any remote work needs. * A fully equipped kitchen to prepare your meals. * A comfortable bedroom with a queen-sized bed. * Coastal-inspired decor with natural textures that capture the warm, authentic spirit of Mystic living.
Wake up to gentle river breezes and enjoy your morning coffee with stunning views of the Mystic Drawbridge. From your patio, you can watch as historic wooden ships are restored at the Seaport Shipyard just across the water.
Access Guests will have completely private access to the entire School House Cottage. Although attached to the main Captain’s House, the cottage has its own separate entrance, ensuring a peaceful and private experience.
Your private access includes: * The entire cottage, including a full kitchen, cozy living room, one bedroom, and one full bathroom. * An in-unit washer and dryer for your convenience. * A private patio with a BBQ grill and outdoor dining area overlooking the river. * One designated parking space on the property. * Complimentary use of provided bikes and a kayak to explore the area.
Please note that while you have your own private patio, the larger backyard area is a shared space.
Details to Note Please be aware of the unique characteristics of this genuine historic property, which are a key part of its charm: * This is an attached cottage, part of a larger historic home. * The stairs leading to the second-floor bedroom are steep, which may not be suitable for guests with mobility issues. * The ceilings in the upstairs bedroom are low, in keeping with the original 1857 schoolhouse design. The most important House Rule is, respect our neighbors and community. Mystic is a quaint, coastal New England town. As hosts, and guests, we share in the responsibility of keeping Mystic a great place to visit, and to LIVE. Honor the noise ordinance. Be the guest that you would want staying in a vacation rental near your home.
Located on the waterfront, this cottage is in Mystic River Historic District, a neighbourhood in Mystic. Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration and Mystic Arts Center are local attractions and those in the mood for shopping can visit Olde Mistick Village and Tanger Outlet Foxwoods. Looking to enjoy an event or a game while in town? See what's happening at Mohegan Sun Arena or Waterford Speedbowl. Visit our Mystic travel guide
Mystic Seaport - The Museum of America and the Sea
13 min walk - 1.1 km
Mystic Arts Center
3 min walk - 0.3 km
Mystic Downtown Marina
6 min walk - 0.6 km
Charles W. Morgan at Mystic Seaport
16 min walk - 1.4 km
Getting around
Mystic Station
12 min walk
New London, CT (GON-Groton - New London)
15 min drive
Restaurants
Mystic Pizza
3 min walk
McDonald's
3 min drive
Sift Bake Shop
3 min walk
The Mystic Diner & Restaurant
3 min drive
Mystic Drawbridge Ice Cream
2 min walk
Frequently asked questions
Is Historic Waterfront School House pet-friendly?
Yes, this property allows cats and dogs (limit 2 total).
How much is parking at Historic Waterfront School House?
On-site parking is available at the property.
What time is check-in at Historic Waterfront School House?
Check-in begins at 4:00 PM.
What time is check-out at Historic Waterfront School House?
Checkout is at 10:00 AM.
Where is Historic Waterfront School House located?
Located in Mystic River Historic District, this cottage is within a 10-minute walk of Mystic River Bascule Bridge and Mystic Downtown Marina. Mystic Arts Center and Mystic Seaport - The Museum of America and the Sea are also within 15 minutes. Mystic Station is 12 minutes by foot.
Have a question?
AI iconBetaBeta
Get instant answers with AI powered search of property information and reviews.
Reviews
Historic Waterfront School House Reviews
9.8
Exceptional
All reviews shown are from real guest experiences. Only travellers who have booked a stay with us can submit a review. We verify reviews according to our guidelines and publish all reviews, positive or negative.More informationOpens in a new window
We had an amazing time staying here while in town for concerts at Mohegan sun. Amazing location perfect for shopping on the main strip, great food within walking distance, and the property owner was perfectly communicative. Would love to stay here again!
We had a great week. Loved the schoolhouse theme throughout as did our granddaughter on her visit. Nice short walk to downtown and great views of the river. We’re looking forward to our next visit in August!
An incredible place to stay! My wife, 2 kids (2 and 1), and dog stayed in the “School House” and it was the perfect space to relax and enjoy. Gerard was extremely accommodating and great at communicating, the house was clean and stocked with anything we might need (pack and play, high chair, baby gate, etc), and the location can’t be beat (just steps away from downtown). We will definitely recommend this place to friends/family, as well as stay again in the future
The location could not be beat. We parked the car and walked everywhere.The view of the river with the glimmering lights of Mystic was beautiful. The snowfall completed the look of a winter wonderland.Gerard, our host, was always available to answer questions.
This was an excellent stay in Mystic. The host was always on point, and the property was very well cared for, and perfectly located. My only observation is the ceiling height in the bedroom. While I understand that this are very old buildings that have been meticulously refurbished, I would suggest letting potential renters know about this issue. I am 6ft, and even my 5,5ft girlfriend hit our heads a few times against the ceiling. We just laughed and enjoyed our stay, but for some people this may not be what they want. However I still give this property and excellent review because of the attemptiveness of the host, the location, and the cute inner decor.
Adorable little apartment right in the center of town. We were able to bring our dogs which was great. Check in and check out were simple. Kitchen was well-stocked for cooking so we enjoyed meals in and out. Would return in the future!
Quaint 1BR accommodations with nice yard for our puppy to run around in on his leash.
! minute to Main St. super convenient!!
All the modern conveniences.
Enjoyable time!!
Whether you are a pizza movie fan or a pizza lover, Mystic is enchanting. This house is walking distance of everything Mystic has to offer. Extremely charming and, without a doubt, the cleanest house we have ever stayed. Definitely worth a visit.
Booked the 1 Bedroom Schoolhouse because it was just me and my Fiancee this trip. So cute and incredibly clean and appointed. Centrally located to enjoy all the shops and restaurants and across the water you can see the Mystic Seaport Museum. The Owner, Gerard, is a great communicator and more importantly a really nice guy. I have had the pleasure of staying at 2 other Great Gull Island properties for family gatherings and they are all great!
We stayed in Mystic the first three days in May. Restored schoolhouse was charming, right on the water and only steps from shopping and restaurants. We walked everywhere. Host was very easy to reach and responsive to our questions and needs. We really did feel like we were back in school in this quaint place!
Loved the historic aspects of the house, combined with the school theme. We appreciated the opportunity to travel with our two dogs. The house is conveniently located less than a block from Main St and the neighborhood was great for a scenic walks. Everything was very clean and there were many conveniences in the house to make you feel at home. Gerardchecked in frequently to make sure everything was going well and nothing was needed. Great communication and smooth check-in/check out process.
This property was probably one of the nicest I have ever stayed in Mystic. Some rentals are just that, rentals, but this truly felt like a home in every way. It was impeccably, clean and decorated, and no detail was spared. Communication with the agent was seamless, and was able to arrange for early check-in. Highly recommend this place and will definitely come back. Walking distance to just about everywhere in downtown Mystic.
We took a short trip to Mystic with our 2 grandchildren. We all loved the charm of the property…a19th century schoolhouse, beautifully renovated and updated, yet keeping with some original features.
The proximity to the downtown area was perfect. We were able to walk everywhere.
The host, Gerard, was a dream to communicate with, checking in with us several times. It was a perfect rental!
All was pretty good. Beautiful kitchen, lots of dishes, utensils, everything you need. Only things of issue - VERY steel stairs with bathroom upstairs. Bed was a bit saggy - rolled to the middle. They came and flipped the topper which was helpful. Gerald stayed in touch very well!
My sister and I stayed at the schoolhouse for four nights, and there was ample space for the two of us. The house was extremely well cared for and clean, the kitchen was nicely stocked with everything we needed, and the bed was very comfortable. The house is within walking distance to many shops, restaurants, and Mystic Seaport Village. Gerard, the host, was very responsive to my questions and very helpful. We had a wonderful time in Mystic. and a large part of our happiness is due to the great communication with the host and the overall condition of the property. I highly recommend staying at this property.
I have been to Mystic many times before, but never have I stayed quite literally in the center of town. The location is absolutely perfect. All of our favorite shops and restaurants were so close. This was particularly convenient for traveling with our twin 1 year olds, as in the mornings we could stroll around and go back and forth to the house at any time. The house itself is indeed charming. The school decor is adorable, and all of the things you’d need (appliances, utensils etc) are available. We took full advantage of the outdoor space as the view of the river is incredible. Although Main Street is just steps away, you still feel a nice sense of privacy. Gerard was the icing on the cake. He was extremely responsive and caring making sure our family was comfortable and had what we needed. A great stay overall, we were extremely happy!
Stayed 2 nights in Sep 2025
Verified review
10/10 Excellent
Fiona
23 Jan 2024
Liked: Cleanliness, amenities, property conditions & facilities, communication
This house was an 11/10...absolutely amazing!! We had very high hopes, and they were even surpassed! From the moment the booking was made Gerard was extremely helpful and accommodating with clear and friendly communication. The house was perfect, with everything that you could possibly need. The property is right in town and everywhere that we went was within easy walking distance. We stayed for 3 nights in January, and used the bikes provided at the house for a gorgeous ride around the Mystic River. The house was extremely clean and everything was very well maintained. The kitchen was fully stocked with pots/pans/appliances allowing us to cook some meals at home. We walked into town for dinner at the Port of Call and had one of the best dinners we have ever had, and then scored some delicious coffee and pastries the next morning at Sift (also within walking distance). There is plenty to do in town and in the surrounding area even in the winter! Can't recommend this spot enough, we had such a lovely getaway!
My partner and I had an amazing post-wedding trip in Mystic. The property's location is it's biggest draw - right in the heart of the downtown area within easy walking distance of shopping, restaurants, and the water. No need to worry about street parking as you have your own parking area. Cottage is cozy and clean without onerous checkout instructions, though be mindful of the low ceilings around the upstairs bed. Property manager was kind and communicative throughout the stay as needed. We had an incredible stay and would be more than happy to spend some time at this site again. Thank you!
Note: Listing states there is a hot tub, though none on premises. Property manager is aware and states it is a problem affecting multiple listings and he is attempting to fix the listing. Did not affect the quality of our stay in any way, but may be useful for future interested guests to be aware in case it is still listed.
We had a wonderful stay at this beautiful and immaculate home right on the majestic Mystic River! Our host was very communicative and kind. What a perfect location - walking distance to the fun restaurants, bars and shopping! Can’t wait to return!
We loved the location of this property and how well it’s maintained. Our host was very attentive throughout our stay. We are looking forward to booking another stay at this property.