Top Hotels Near Magens Bay in St. Thomas from AU$141

"If you’re looking for an authentic St. Thomas experience, Bluebeard’s Castle is it. We stayed at Pirates Pension area and honestly couldn’t have asked for a better spot. For context, we have been to St. Thomas 10x and have stayed all across the island, north, south, east, and west, in everything from resorts to Airbnbs. So when we say this is one of the best bang for your buck stays on the island, we mean it. The views from up on the hill are absolutely stunning. You can see the harbor and the Caribbean stretching out forever and it never gets old. The resort itself is well kept and has that perfect mix of laid back island vibes with everything you need. The on site restaurant was a real standout. The food was delicious, the seafood and fresh mangos were incredible and the atmosphere in there was just right. Exactly the kind of place where you lose track of time over a good meal. And don’t sleep on the drinks, the adult beverages were plenty strong and kept the good times going all afternoon. The pool area was great (3.5 foot deep) and one of our favorite spots on the property (kids)It felt super safe, surprisingly quiet, and never overcrowded. Perfect for just floating around and unwinding with zero stress. The location is great too. Close enough to Charlotte Amalie to explore the shops and local history, but tucked away enough that it feels like a true escape. If you’re planning a trip to St. Thomas, don’t overthink it. Bluebeard’s Castle delivered!!!"

"Nice atmosphere especially for those who enjoy outdoors. There are many small seating areas around the site where you can grasp the beauty of nature. "

"Beautiful house! As private as the name might suggest! Full amenities, kitchen supplies, comfy beds, etc. Would recommend to my friends and look forward to coming back to your wonderful house with an absolutely spectacular view! One last thing: I agree with the recommendation for a good sturdy car (maybe with 4x4) to get around the island (we got a jeep and it was a good decision)."

"This was a lovely hotel to stay in. The staff in the office were very helpful with accommodating cabs for us. Shout out to Elizabeth for her positive energy and spirit!"

"This is a great place and a great value. If I could change only one little thing it would be to get the water in the shower a little more hot; it’s not cold but not quite hot—a little over lukewarm. I’m sure this could be a quick fix from a maintenance engineer. There is a little road noise, as well, which you can’t help being that close to the main road. Overall, it is a really great hotel that is easy to get to and close to everything (ferry, airport, restaurants/shops, and my work. I travel every other month for work, and I will likely stay again (if they can heat up the water a little ;0). "

"We were a group of 7 ranging in age from 12-81. This was as family trip for us, first time in St. Thomas. The house is amazing! Loved how the kitchen and main area is set in the middle and bedrooms are spread out. The pool was wonderful and the views are amazing from every area. We cooked for most meals and the kitchen is very well equipped. We had groceries ordered ahead of time from The Market which Sati delivered for us. We noticed that a lot of our cold groceries were missing- as it was Easter Sunday we figured nothing would be open. They were open and were so apologetic about missing our cold groceries they delivered them that morning! Cost-u-Less and Moe's were also great for groceries. The beaches are beautiful-loved Magen's Beach which is so close to the house. Sapphire was beautiful as well. Would definitely recommend checking the cruise ship schedule as the beaches get crowded quickly. We soon learned to get to the beach by 9 and had no problems with getting chairs. Day trip to St. John was definitely worth it as well. Driving wasn't an issue for us, but can be a bit intimidating if you aren't used to driving on the left. Would definitely recommend Magen's Hideaway for anyone. Neighborhood was quiet and perfect for morning walks- lots of hills!! The only problem is that the house is so nice that it's hard to leave to explore the island! "

"Our second visit to Ocean's Edge, yet certainly not our last. Very comfortable and functional for three couples plus one child. While it's easy to spend days lounging around the pool and taking in the breeze and the view, the villa is conveniently located to everything else on STT."

"What a tropical paradise! We were blown away by Hideaway! If you are looking for a private, family or couple getaway, this is the best place around! The simplicity might be a little less than what some want, but the stay met every one of our needs. The environment was beautiful and the beach was our favorite on the island! Little touches everywhere were not overlooked by my family. "

"Beautiful home! Property manager made it easy to get oriented to the home. Amazing view of the bay. Home was clean and prepared for our visit. Definitely hoping to do it again "