Best Greencastle Villas: Private & Luxury Villa Accommodations in Greencastle

A beach with turquoise water, palm trees, and colorful picnic tables.

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

In two weeks

In two months

In three months

In four months

No exact matches found, but these alternatives could be just right

Recommended hotels in Greencastle

Rosebud

Rock Sound

BriAnna

includes taxes & fees

13 July - 14 July

Comfort Single Room, Courtyard View | Garden view

Hilton's Haven

Tarpum Bay

Ashley

includes taxes & fees

13 July - 14 July

Cozy Nook Studio apartment in Perfect Getaway Tarpum Bay with AC, WiFi & kitchen

Tarpum Bay

IAN S.

includes taxes & fees

11 Aug - 12 Aug

The Pilot House Boutique Suite #3 Rock Sound

Rock Sound

includes taxes & fees

11 Aug - 12 Aug

The Pilot House - Private 4-Suite Estate, Sleeps 8

Rock Sound

includes taxes & fees

13 July - 14 July

Cape Eleuthera Resort & Marina

Freetown

Tiffany

includes taxes & fees

1 Aug - 2 Aug

The Pilot House Boutique Suite #4 Rock Sound

Rock Sound

Claire F.

includes taxes & fees

13 July - 14 July

View all properties

Find holiday rentals that suit your style

Private holiday homes

Apartments

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Top Greencastle Hotel Reviews

Historic Home Directly on Windermere Beach w/Club

10/10 Excellent

"Our recent Provender House 1 week stay was excellent. 1. The drive to the house on Windemere is beautiful just to start. 2. The view from the house to the pink sand beach is stunning. Several of our party exclaimed about it when we first entered the door. You are on 5 miles of beautiful pink sand beach with a normally gentle surf - as the reef breaks the waves. During our stay I only saw two people far down the beach one day, and another day one person walked by us. Plus, it is a less than a 5-minute drive or bike ride to the other side of Windemere island where you will find a completely calm beach and “beach club” with a shaded pavilion. We saw turtles and a friendly dolphin there. 3. The house is well maintained and comfortable with a quite well-equipped kitchen. Note that they can configure the bedrooms with 2 twin beds into kings if you need different sleeping arrangements than those shown on the listing. 4. Pam (the rental agent) provided excellent information on dining and activities on Eleuthera. Pam was very responsive to all our questions and made great suggestions. 5. The Property manager Bobbette and her husband William went way beyond to resolve any issues we had, including getting a water tank truck and plumber out in short order when our tank went dry (apparently because the Eleuthera water system wasn't functioning well one day) 6. All in all, a great stay at an idyllic location!"

Seabreeze Cottage - Steps to own private beach.

10/10 Excellent

"Just a tiny mix-up at check in that host quickly rectified...absolutely didn't bother us one bit just how things are sometimes. The cottage is comfortable and felt exactly how I want our vacation home to feel...like you're staying at a friend's and they're happy to have you. Loved the big porches on front and back. Beautiful grounds and so peaceful. Used the gazebo area near the beach to lounge and read while enjoying the view and ocean breeze. What a fantastic place to stay and a wonderful person to work with. Would 100% recommend and stay again."

Private Villa Directly on Windermere Beach, Private Pool, Tennis

10/10 Excellent

"A beautiful home with a short walk to the beach! We had a wonderful time at Wave's End. The beach was beautiful, pink sand and not another person in sight. Clotilda, the housekeeper, did a wonderful job of keeping the house clean. Cardi, the caretaker, was great. The power went out and the generator broke but before we knew it wasn't working, Cardi was already working on getting it fixed. We couldn't have asked for a better home to celebrate our 20th anniversary! I would definitely stay here again and highly recommend renting."

ULTRA LUX Coconut Cove-FULL SOLAR- Pool-Golf Course!3acre 300 ft PINK SAND BEACH

10/10 Excellent

"Chris the host was great to deal with on any questions. House is awesome and plenty of stuff to do at the house that if you don’t want to leave you don’t need too. Overall a great value"

Lux New Windermere Home w/Pool, Boat Dock, Beach Access, Club Membership

10/10 Excellent

"Wonderful experience! House was clean and very comfortable, and nice location on Savannah Sound and easy walk to the beach. Beautiful sunsets! Dock was great for turtle watching and easy launch in kayaks or paddle boards to explore the beautiful Savannah Sound. We will be back"

Oceanfront Cottage Near Restaurant, Stores

10/10 Excellent

"Our stay at this beautiful beach house in Rock Sound, Eleuthera was absolutely wonderful. The home was spotless from the moment we walked in, and it had that authentic Bahamian charm that makes you instantly feel like you're on island time. The wrap‑around porch was one of our favorite features perfect for morning coffee, evening breezes, and just soaking in the peaceful surroundings. Inside, we had all the comforts of home, including AC and Wi‑Fi, which made relaxing after long beach days even better. The location couldn't have been more convenient. We were just minutes away from grocery stores, a gas station, the clinic, and the pharmacy. Most beaches were only a 15–20 minute drive, and the turquoise water nearby was absolutely breathtaking. We were also able to explore the entire island with ease from Harbour Island to Spanish Wells and even enjoyed local events like the Conch Festival in Deep Creek and the Pineapple Festival in Governor's Harbour. Being based in Rock Sound made everything accessible without feeling crowded or touristy. If you're looking for a clean, comfortable, well‑located home with true Bahamian charm, this rental is a fantastic choice. We loved our stay and would absolutely return."

The Pilot House Boutique Suite #4 Rock Sound

10/10 Excellent

"Karen was an exceptional host: flexible, professional, helpful and friendly. I highly recommend the Pilot House if you visit Eleuthera. Some scheduling irregularities arose and Karen was proactive and resolved in to our liking. Also the gardens are immaculate and beautiful"

Contemporary Beachfront Escape with Private Pool on Windermere's World-Famous Pink Sand Beach

10/10 Excellent

"Coralli is an absolutely stunning home! From the moment you walk up to the front door, the views are breathtaking. It is ideally situated for long walks on the pink sand beach, swimming, or paddleboarding. The house is thoughtfully equipped with everything you might need for a relaxing beach vacation."

Find out more about Greencastle

Greencastle Villas information

Number of reviews	29
Accommodation	16 Villas
Lowest Price	AU$201
Highest Price	AU$690

Search Greencastle Villa Accommodation

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Recommended hotels in Greencastle

Rosebud

Hilton's Haven

Cozy Nook Studio apartment in Perfect Getaway Tarpum Bay with AC, WiFi & kitchen

The Pilot House Boutique Suite #3 Rock Sound

The Pilot House - Private 4-Suite Estate, Sleeps 8

Cape Eleuthera Resort & Marina

The Pilot House Boutique Suite #4 Rock Sound

Find holiday rentals that suit your style

Top Greencastle Hotel Reviews

Historic Home Directly on Windermere Beach w/Club

Find out more about Greencastle

Greencastle Villas information