This house was really lovely and much larger inside than the photos give credit for and made for an awesome long weekend away from the city.
A couple of notes (not necessarily complaints) on the property:
- the lawn is very small and sloped, so it's not really a great space for lawn games, etc. as the water is very close
- there were only 1-2 very old and mostly busted lawn chairs aside from the small old wooden ones shown. recommend bringing your own stadium chairs, etc.
- the master bedroom never really cools down. we had the a/c blasting, fans, blinds closed, everything, and it just couldn't keep up with the sun. the rest of the house did cool down nicely, though - definitely keep the curtains in the living room closed all day.
- the gas grill and charcoal grill are very small. It was fine for our group of 5, but a large group would take a while or need to use both
- bring your own condiments; we usually expect there to be some leftover from other guests but the kitchen was empty aside from a few spices
- pots/pans/etc. are scarce and a bit dated as some others mentioned
- there is a neighbor directly to your left so the property isn't entirely private
- the sand bar in the lake is awesome and hopping. we stopped every day and anchored off and hung out. It ranges from 2-4 feet deep in places and is mostly a very pleasant sandy bottom
- firewood is not provided
- there are extra towels in the cupboard in the master, however they're all white and old and not formal beach towels just to be aware
- renting from Butterfield's Landing is not an awesome process. they take cash only, don't document things properly (or at all - you won't get any confirmation and they don't do anything online), and change up when they're available at their own discretion. we were told we could drop off first thing Sunday and not be charged, only for him to tell me that he wouldn't be there until 1 on Sunday, so I had to pay for a half-day. Not what I was told when I rented but not a humongous deal. Just be sure you put things in explicit, clear writing with them.