Independent in Edgartown
Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check prices for these dates
Tonight
10 Aug - 11 AugTomorrow
11 Aug - 12 AugThis weekend
14 Aug - 16 AugNext weekend
21 Aug - 23 Aug
Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in
Top Edgartown Hotel Reviews
Edgar Hotel Martha's Vineyard, an Ascend Collection Hotel
10/10 Excellent
"Enjoyed our stay, quiet, convenient to everything in Edgartown!"
The Christopher, The Edgartown Collection
10/10 Excellent
"The Christopher is officially my new favorite hotel. Bailey greeted us when we arrived and was the primary person we saw during our stay. She was lovely and so helpful. I could have fainted when she offered to have our super heavy luggage taken up 3 flights of stairs for us! We were upgraded free of charge to a larger room that had its own private deck. The room was beautiful - gorgeous furnishings and so clean and comfortable. There are homemade, sinfully delicious chocolate chip cookies served at 3 pm - we actually raced back to the hotel for these; they were so good! And the homemade breakfasts served each morning with delicious, strong coffee were a welcome way to start the day. I've already started planning a girls' trip to the island and The Christopher is where we'll stay!"
Harbor View Hotel
10/10 Excellent
"We had an amazing stay and we can not wait to be back."
4-bedroom house in lovely Edgartown..Centrally located
10/10 Excellent
"Perfect location near downtown and other activities! The house had everything we needed and the back deck was awesome. The host was communicative and made check-in easy! Can't wait to come back."
Faraway Martha's Vineyard
10/10 Excellent
"We came here on our anniversary and could not have picked a better place. The boutique-yet-full-service hotel is elegant and beautiful, with great taste everywhere and amazing ocean views. The heated (perfect temperature) pool and jacuzzi were a perfect spot to take a break at any time in the day, with relaxing and happy lounge music. Most importantly, the staff is highly well trained, educated, and devoted to service with a smile without the attitude sometimes found in premium hotels sometimes. Mattia (spelling?), Duna, Julian were amazing. Coffee in the room a great plus! Short walk from the ferry (3 minutes!) and in the center of the action makes this hard to beat. I would only add more obvious breakfast choices (most guests just go out to great options short walks away) to make this even more perfect. We will certainly be back."
Newly Renovated Apartment in the heart of Edgartown on the Bike Path!
10/10 Excellent
"Walking distance to downtown Edgartown and a good starting place for other parts of the island. Landlord very available to answer questions"
The Lightkeepers Inn
8/10 Good
"We enjoyed our stay: the main bedroom was fine with a wonderful bed, linens etc. would b better w more storage area: no place for storing clothes! Definitely need more hangers! Also needs some art on walls—pretty austere! Sofa bed in living not comfortable; mattress quite thin and hard. Kitchen area well-stocked and attractive. Bathroom well stocked and fine; had to call for an iron, but otherwise fine. Main issue: we were not sent a code to get in when arriving on a late ferry; by sheer luck we ran into a property manager, Lauren, who helped us! This could have been a serious problem! Communication needs to be better and more frequent since there is often no one on site!"
Charming 2-bedroom house on Chappy with pool, Tennis, pickleball, WiFi and AC
10/10 Excellent
"Overall, this home was absolutely fabulous for our family holiday! The main house is ideal for adults, The pool house features a bathroom, kitchenette, and an outdoor shower just steps away from the pool and courts. While we had a wonderful time, there are several unique details about the property's layout and location that we wish we had known before our journey. The living area is upstairs, while two bedrooms and two bathrooms are downstairs. If you are traveling with older individuals or anyone with mobility issues, this layout may not be ideal. The primary bathroom's shower is located outside. My mother, who celebrated her 80th birthday during this trip, thought it was an experience of a lifetime, but it’s definitely something to keep in mind! Nearby towns are close to Edgartown, you can easily explore one town per day! You will be taking a ferry back and forth every time you want to leave Chappy. With a Vehicle: It cost us 27 return for 3 people. Pedestrian, 5 return. There is absolutely nothing to buy or eat on Chappy Island. You must be completely stocked up on groceries before you cross over. Chappaquiddick feels incredibly remote at first. Do not trust your GPS once you turn right onto Narragansett Ave. Stay on the road until it dead-ends and forces you to turn either Right or Left. Turn Left. Immediately take another hard Left. Follow that road until you see the tennis courts, then just follow the remaining road straight in. We will be back."
Chappy Summer Cabin!
10/10 Excellent
"Property owners were the true meaning of customer service. Great communication and very friendly. Second summer we rented and already looking forward to next year. Plenty of room and parking with great privacy. 5 minutes from Chappy ferry and the 3 beaches. Thank you Rusty and Nora!"