Cay Bay Hotels, Cole Bay

"We have been to St Martin many times and this was the best place we have stayed, by far. The staff was amazing, the room was spacious and included a small kitchen. The location, on the beach, was also amazing. We can't say enough about the staff to include the reception, the maid service and the dining staff. You couldn't ask for better service from the gals in the dining are."

"The property was 10/10 the only thing I did not like is that you can’t order food after 11pm and you can’t get food delivered to the property. They also don’t have a snack bar or vending machine, so definitely get all the snacks and food you need for the night. "

"Excellent facilty, grounds well kept, very clean, staff is very friendly. Ryan and Arnaldo made our welcome very pleasant, and Natasha made some great recommendations. Well run hotel."

"Loved our stay"

"We loved every minute! "

"The staff at Oyster Pond were excellent and they provided a good range of free entertainment. The daily happy hours at the bar (buy one/get one free) was great. The outdoor pool was refreshing, with lounge chairs and umbrellas always available. The only drawback is the beach, due to the sargassum (seaweed) there is a smell and it has to be raked daily. If you’re content with the pool, it’s a great place to stay, however if the beach is a must for you, consider staying elsewhere on the Caribbean side."

"Great location very nice accommodations! "

"Kitchen fully equipped. Parking availble. Friendly staff. "

"We went from August 31 to September 6 of 2025 and it was a lot better than we anticipated. The beaches are beyond gorgeous. This hotel is fun. The food is absolutely delicious. Good vibes all around."