City Island Fishing Holidays

This place was a good place to stay! Wished they had amenities like fridge and microwave. But it was good location to places and good location to time square!

Surprisingly wonderful all around.

Room was clean, and very quiet. The highlight of the trip was the staff - front desk, doormen and maintenance were always friendly and welcoming, especially with our daughter. Wonderful stay.

⭐⭐⭐⭐ Great Value, Comfortable Beds & Convenient Location We stayed at the Shelburne Sonesta from Aug 28–Sept 1 in a double queen room with a kitchenette. Overall, we had a great stay and felt it was well worth the price. Check-in was quick and easy, and our room was clean and spacious. The sheets were soft and the beds were VERY comfortable after long days exploring New York. A fun bonus was choosing two treats from the hotel’s snack stash each night, including chips, Gatorade, pop, water, juice and cookies. It was a simple perk, but we really enjoyed it! The location was convenient, with the subway nearby, easy Uber access and taxis generally available out front. Many main attractions were also within walking distance. The attached restaurant offers room service, but we ate there instead and enjoyed fries, wings and drinks. Everything was great, and the hotel staff were very helpful throughout our stay. A couple of things to note: the TV didn’t support streaming apps, so we were limited to regular cable. The phone in our room also didn’t work properly, meaning we had to call the front desk using speakerphone. The room was clean overall, though it didn’t feel deeply cleaned. A little more attention to detail would have helped, but it didn’t affect our stay. Overall, we enjoyed the comfortable beds, convenient location, helpful staff and kitchenette. For the price, it was definitely worth it, and we would stay again.

Always the best :) My favorite hotel and location :)