Plum Island Fishing Holidays

The best thing this hotel has is the location. Staff is not the most helpful neither not helpful, they are OK.... They talk to you and tell you everything you are supposed to know at check in so quickly so they can finish with you and continue doing what they are doing... The property is a nice one but details start to make it look that needs an update. The corners of all the lobby dark wood pieces are all chipped. Easy fix paint them dark again so you can't see them. Same in the elevators that need more cleaning on the walls and definitely on the elevator's rugs: you can see the dirt in the corners of the rugs that are not the same exact size as the elevator's floors. TLC and maintenance is needed. I am surprised Expedia has this hotel as a 9.0. For this elevated kind of reviews you need more than just location. Room was nice and clean but same again all wood furniture and drawers are chipped. Easy fix get maintenance to paint this regularly. I was given a room next to a closed drainage pipe???? I don't know but my bathroom smelled funky and lots of noises from the bathroom wall. I would give it an 8.0 review

The staff is super friendly and accommodating. The hotel is located right in front of the famous L’industrie Pizza and down the street is Little Italy with many great restaurants. There famous caffe Paradiso is only a 7 min walk and a 5 min walk to Leons bagels! The hotel provided a free water dispenser down in their lobby as well as free coffee and teas. They also provide free yummy croissants in the mornings. I would definitely stay here again.

Reputation of Parking Lot is not good... so needed to part another place.

Went with family. Would stay again.

I loved the location of this property, the staff was very nice, and easy access to the subway. Having a CVS across the street was very convenient as well. I just wish they had a better selection of the continental breakfast and their happy hour bar prices are a little bit too high. However, it was still delicious. Please put in mini fridges.

Everything about this hotel was fantastic! The room was lovely, staff was accommodating and helpful, housekeeping did a great job each day, and included in the price of the room was an outstanding daily breakfast buffet as well as a light dinner service. In addition, the hotel is conveniently located just blocks from the theater district and MoMA. We will be staying here each time we come to NYC. Highly recommend!!

No comment it’s not a 5 start hotel

Great property. Nice quiet location in lower Manhattan right by Seaport and Wall Street (and subway). Room is basically an apartment (my one BR Gourmet had full kitchen and two full baths). Cool property with lots of great common areas. Great staff. Will stay again.

Went with family. Would stay again.

Amazing. Great service. Great location