Randall's Island Fishing Holidays

Lovely bar and restaurant. Historic location.

I absolutely loved this hotel. Very clean and nice and accommodating and great staff!

Loved the property. Clean and good sized rooms with great service.

We love the W. Customer service all around is the best. We had room service for breakfast and e writhing was cooked exactly as requested.,delicious. The previous night we stopped at the bar and Patrick the bar tender was super friendly and knowledgeable. Gave us an eduction on vodka martinis.

The WiFi was spotty the two days we were staying. The staff gave us a modem but that didn’t help much. If you’re on vacation but still needing to work, I wouldn’t stay here. But for convenience and location—access to KTown—were excellent!

The Manager resolved a small problem that I encountered. He was very courteous and respectful.

The pool is really nice, but it's only available for guests without a pool reservation for 3 hours in the morning.

I absolutely loved this hotel. Very clean and nice and accommodating and great staff!

Check in was at 3. Room was rdy at 6

Great location right on the beach. Was a little confused by instructions on how to access the amenities (beach, pool, etc). Would have preferred to have been given a sheet of paper or have something in the room with the info. It was hard to remember it all and the front desk stayed busy so it took waiting in line to ask questions. Pool was out of towels for the entire hour+ we were there. But pool was nice. View from roof top was fantastic. Room was clean, smart set up for coming from beach. Would definitely stay again.

Wonderful. Clean, quiet, comfortable. Great amenities such as pool and amazing rooftop bar. Definitely would stay again. Received a bottle of wine for being silver member with expedia.