The Rooftop at Pier 17 Tours and Activities

The room was clean but paint needs touch up. Made it feel dingy. Property was clean. Breakfast was plain. Try better coffee & more hot breakfast but the complimentary is always a plus for something light and quick. Staff was nice and helpful. Wish the ice machine wasn’t in the basement and there’s no doors on the shower. Other than small nuances the stay was great. Good location.

I got sold based on the reviews and pictures. 8.0 should be pretty good. I was very disappointed once I walked in to the hotel. Everything was smaller than the pictures made them out to be. The bedroom had a balcony. This balcony opened up to the hidden sides of the buildings. I called it the gates of hell. Not worth even mentioning room had balcony. The worst part of the experience was the mattress. We got a queen mattress with a hole on one side where you could fall in and feel the springs dig into your back. After much complaining we got the mattress replaced with one that was a little less worn out, but still you could sink in. These beds were awful. The AC could barely cool the room and it wasn’t even that hot. Service was ok. It is a hotel in the wall hotel where they don’t really have any staff or amenities. I didn’t even get to see that nice picture with outside seating. Location was great, cleanness was ok. No roaches like we had in NJ. Guess it’s par for a NJ hotel.

I was very pleasantly surprised. I chose it because of the location and price and was so nervous taking kids to NYC by myself if I chose wrong. Such a pleasant surprise! Room was small but fine and felt high end and in safe neighborhood. I would def go again!