Search Preston Cottage Accommodations

"Convenient,"

"Phenomenal communication with Becky, our host. Will be coming to this property again. It is unique and unlike anything I ever stayed at before. It was a jail in its former life after all. Very authentic with a modern twist. Great place!!!"

"Wonderful cinnamon rolls "

"Very nice perfect for us, would rent again!"

"I love the location of this cabin. It is right in the heart of Amish country. The cabin and surrounding property are beautiful and peaceful. It is very spacious and comfortable. Craig is a great host. He checked in with us to see if we had any questions or needs. This was my third time staying there and I plan to make it an annual event."

"Sheena was a very friendly and responsive host. The Cozy Cottage was clean, comfortable, and included all of the amenities we needed and a few extras, like coffee and flavored creamers! We will definitely choose the Cozy Cottage for our next stay in Mabel!"

"Great historic place that has great charm."

"Dan was super nice and accommodating. If you are looking for a 5 star hotel, look elsewhere. It you want a large, clean farmhouse, this place is for you. Being a working family farm, expect to see a tractor or two going in and out. We really enjoyed sitting on the wrap around porch with a book watching the cows. Lilly, the family's dog, was super friendly and may come to visit you. We will definitely go back! Thanks again Dan!"