Top Hotels Near Lobster Cay in

"I had the most wonderful stay! The staff were so wonderful and friendly and accommodating. They set up a golf cart rental for me on arrival and took care of all the arrangements. The food & drinks at their bar was excellent. The location is conveniently just footsteps from the water taxi. The room was enormous, clean, and had everything you could ever need for your trip. A great coffee shop right next door. And that pink sand beach was far better than I imagined it would be. My only regret is that I couldn’t stay longer … but I will most definitely be back and I will be staying at this hotel again. Thanks for an unforgettable experience "

"Everything was great from check-in until check-out "

"FABULOUS HOME! We absolutely loved our stay here. April was a fantastic host and Brandi who picked us up from the ferry was a dream! We will be booking here again!"

"This is a gem , clean room , friendly staff. Juanita have all your needs ,she has contact for everything in Harbour island and Eleuthera. We stayed off season and she made sure we had everything we needed during our stay. Nice on site restaurant as well! Can’t go wrong! "

"We had a fabulous stay at the house! Everything was perfect! Carole arranged for our transportation from the airport to the dock and the ferry ride over to Spanish Wells. Once we arrived at Spanish Wells dock Audrey the caretaker was waiting for us and escorted us back to the house. Our golf cart rental was also prearranged and waiting at the dock when we arrived. The house was spotless and had everything you would need. Plenty of beach toys, beach towels even sunscreen! The views from the porch are beautiful and it is about a 1-2 minute walk to the most serene beach I’ve ever seen. We had the beach to ourselves all week. Audrey was excellent and quick to respond to any questions and arranged a boat tour which I highly recommend. I would definitely return and recommend this place to anyone looking for a quiet, peaceful relaxed vacation."

"Great house and locational "

"Highly recommend! Candia was incredibly accommodating—she took care of everything from reserving the golf cart to booking our ferry and taxi. We didn’t have to stress about a thing and felt right at home from the moment we arrived. Mermaid Cove was spotless and very welcoming. The backyard is super peaceful and relaxing, and we especially loved spending time on the private beach. We’ll definitely be coming back!"

"Great place, half a block from a great beach to lounge in the water and walks in the sand."

"Absolutely amazing!We had the privilege of being the first guests to stay at Sweet Bahama Blue for four nights in March 2025, and what an amazing property! It is a destination unto itself! Beth was excellent about communicating with us prior to our arrival and throughout our stay. As this was our first trip to Spanish Wells, Beth met us at the dock with our rented golf cart and gave us the "Grand Tour" of the island, pointing out places to shop and eat, as well as providing some great local information. Once we arrived at the house, it was stunning! We quickly settled in and soon discovered that every possible detail had been tended to -- from the most comfortable beds, to well organized ammenities (beach chairs and kayaks), to plenty of bottled water, solar power, and a cistern water supply (so we'd never be without water or power). We enjoyed relaxing on the deck(s) overlooking the beautiful Bahama blue water, playing ping pong, and going for a trip out in one of the four kayaks provided. Beth was so very welcoming and kind, even scheduling our golf cart rental, the taxis to and from the Gene's Bay Dock, and a boat excursion for us during our stay. I can't recommend this property enough -- and am already looking forward to our next visit to Spanish Wells and Russel Island. It is truly a paradise!"