Summary: This place is perfect.
So, I imagine that this home is what it is like if your grandparents/parents have a seaside home that you go to as a family each year. This is a real-life classic seaside home you are borrowing--it has family pictures, a fully stocked kitchen, games, books, a hammock, a grill with charcoal provided, and of course the two chairs looking out on to Frenchman's Bay, with glorious sunsets. It is just idyllic (the first time I have ever described a VRBO home as such).
If you want sleek/new/regular, this isn't it. The house is gloriously old--the stairs creak, the floor shakes a bit, the dishwasher makes a little noise. It's a real seaside cottage, not a made for VRBO investment property. You just feel like the house has always been part of your life.
Finally, the home is spotless--cleaner than our own!! Sue is a wonderful host--responsive during your planning, and willing to help you settle-in. The community is lovely, though it did take a little time for us to adjust to the expectation that everyone waves at you, and a return wave is part of the deal.
It was just a wonderful experience. Even our millennial kids, are impressed by few things, thought it was great!! Just a wonderful experience!!