Fire Island Pines Holidays from AU$3,146

The hotel is a tired facility, but the staff was helpful. Most importantly, the bed and bedding were comfortable and clean.

Six of us stayed here for the weekend and booked 3 rooms. The positives: - Great location! - Rooms are very spacious - The building has Black Seed Bagels and a Fresh Juice place as well a coffee shop - The lobby has a coffee bar and a drinks bar - The daytime reception staff and bell staff are very friendly - One of the rooms had a slight view of the empire state building Areas of improvement: - The hotel is very dimly lit. The lobby as well as the rooms are very dim. It is hard to get ready in such a poorly lit room - The night staff manager wasn't very friendly and borderline rude - There is no coffee machine in the room BUT coffee bar in the lobby makes up for it - One of the rooms had an issue with the drain of their shower and the another one had an issue with their toilet running all night - The queen beds are small for 2 people We stayed for just the weekend. I wouldn't for a longer stay, The dim lighting isn't very enticing for a repeat stay.

clean and size of the room.

This hotel had clean, comfortable rooms and the staff was great to work with. The hotel is convenient when walking to Penn Station.

Loved the historical charm of this hotel and the excellent service.