Beach Hotels in Rum Cay

"DO NOT RENT THIS PROPERTY. Nothing matches the listing—dirty, trashy yard, broken oven, no advertised BBQ, two broken TVs, broken door locks, dilapidated/unsafe deck, broken deck chairs, rusted utensils, moldy sponges, corroded fixtures, soiled bedsheets and towels, no bright pillows or rugs as shown in the photos, no screens in the windows - they were laying outside on the ground, and a strong odor of cat urine. We found the cat trying to get in the house. I have lots of photos to back up everything I have stated.. It was so shocking the state the house was in. We complained immediately after we picked our jaws up off the floor. The caretaker was confrontational, and the owner promised a refund if we didn't leave a bad review and then ghosted us. Photos are doctored, the house is poorly maintained, and it was a completely disappointing experience. This is our fifth trip to the Bahamas and we have never encountered anything even remotely like this place. VRBO should take the listing down until it is safe to rent and accurate photos are taken"

"Absolutely beautiful beach and resort! Great place to do nothing and unwind. The dinner and bar staff was wonderful. Met some fun people. Receptionists could have paid better attention to front desk. Our room was never cleaned."

"This home is nothing shy of AMAZING! We enjoyed our stay so much. We highly recommend doing more than one week as there is so much on the island to explore, and this house is so perfect that you’ll enjoy every moment spent at it. You get to see sunrise and sunset all from the same deck, snorkel coral reefs right in front of the house, swim/sunbathe in the nice warm pool, kayak with the provided kayaks. On top of this the caretaker is wonderful at answering any questions or concerns during your stay, and he even took us to his garden, stopped in with food he cooked, and shared all his island knowledge with us. Trust me when I say you will not want to leave! "

"It is a beautiful place even though it is being renovated after the hurricane. A bit expensive with little amenities : no breakfast only coffee. even though it was my second time staying there. First time November 2022. Only because I am a native of SanSalvador."

"This home is beautiful!"

"Beautiful setting, peaceful, great location. We’ll be back. "

"Great Spot "

"Amazing place! Charles and Teresa were so hospitable! "

"We had the most amazing stay! The house was superbly located on an elevation that allowed for 360 views from the wrap around veranda. Well-appointed kitchen with everything we needed for our stay. The beach is a short walk with access to explore the many reefs by snorkeling. The host was welcoming and responsive. Loved it!"