Hotels with Pool & Resorts in Big Pine Key from AU$312

"It just looks nothing like the pictures. You come in off a busy highway to a 1950’s motel that has been nicely updated, rooms and bathrooms small but modernized, looking out of the patio doors into lawn and pool. Nice, but not what the pictures say. Busy highway doesn’t keep you awake. Complementary bikes, kayaks, and paddle boards. It is expensive, but cheap for the Florida Keys. I guess it was a deal. Not 4-5 star though. "

"Old school Key West motel, with a nice pool and comfortable, clean rooms. Our room was spotless, and kept clean every day. Free coffee every morning at the outdoor Tiki Hut by the water, and a handy microwave and refrigerator in the room. Everyone we interacted with was friendly, helpful, and welcoming. By the end of the week, we felt like family! Parking was assigned per room, and was easy and convenient. We thoroughly enjoyed our week here, and would absolutely return. "

"Hotel was old but clean. The Tiki hut bar is right there in the middle so when they have a band or music playing then you will be hearing it until they are done late night. Had cold Ac and hot shower so basically what is needed."

"Very clean well cared for property, staff is exceptional"

"We had a really nice overnight at Captain Pips. Ate dinner at Porky's which was a short walk away. Our room was clean and had just what we needed (Starfish efficiency.) We used the kayaks in the morning and also the bikes. It was so nice to have access to those amenities! The staff were friendly and helpful! "

"Yes "

"Beautiful property! Location was perfect for more laid back"

"we did not have a waterview room. Air conditioner was a bit noisy. It was chilly when we were in town so thankfully the ceiling fan was enough for us."

"I was extremely disappointed with the Hammerhead floating cabin. It looked nothing like the photos. The listing shows a bright, clean, fresh space with clear windows, but in reality the walls and ceiling were in rough condition and poorly maintained. Cleanliness was a major issue. There was a large fish hook left on the decking that could have injured my dog or me. Trash was stuffed in the patio table umbrella hole, a beer cap was left on the deck, crumbs were around the toaster, residue was smeared on the countertops, and dirt was on the floor. The windows were so dirty you could barely see out. The setup was uncomfortable and poorly arranged. The dining table sat directly next to the window AC unit, making it loud with cold air blowing on us. You couldn’t properly face the TV from the table, and from the couch you had to turn your head sideways. The couch was extremely uncomfortable and worn. There was no hot water in the shower. In the bedroom, cords were shoved beside the nightstand, which could be a safety issue for kids. A note asking for a cleaning tip $$ which felt inappropriate given the condition. It also wasn’t disclosed that someone would enter Thursday morning to service the toilet, what an inconvenience. The “view” was mostly a rusted boat and gas can. Overall, it was a major letdown. Maybe, the other floating cabins were maintained better???? "