Top Hotels Near Atlantic Golf Course in Water Mill from AU$201

"Simple and very easy check-in. In fact, we got our room about 2 hours early. The staff were very helpful. Room was as described. Well appointed and we appreciated the balcony looking out to the marina. Quiet and comfortable. The continental breakfast was okay. It was as advertised but, not like a breakfast at one of the hotel chains with any eggs, bacon, sausage, waffles, etc.. It had coffee and a no-caffine tea which was a plus, as well as fruit (fresh blueberries), bagels, muffins, yogurt, several cereals and juice. Checkout was very easy and we were even asked if we needed help with our bags. I would highly recommend the Sag Harbor Inn. Great place, great people and a great value. "

"Convenient "

"By far the one of the cleanest houses we’ve ever rented. The house is well maintained and cared for, and the property was bigger than expected. The tennis court was the highlight of our trip - we used it everyday and the kids loved it. Would love to stay when the pool is opened. Julie, the owner, was in contact with me during our stay and made sure everything was going well. We had one issue that she addressed it quickly by sending her maintenance person right away (it was a quick fix). Would stay definitely stay again. "

"The amenities were incredible and the host was so helpful! He send us videos to show us how to use everything to make sure we could enjoy it properly !! "

"We had an absolutely exceptional stay at Head of the Pond in Water Mill, and I cannot say enough about the experience, particularly the care and attention brought by Monika, the owner. We stayed in the two-bedroom cottage by the pond, and from the moment we arrived, it was clear this property is operated at a level far beyond a typical bed and breakfast. The cottage was in pristine condition—immaculately clean, beautifully maintained, and thoughtfully appointed with all the amenities you would expect from a fine hotel. Every detail felt intentional. What truly set this stay apart was the fully stocked kitchen, complete with an abundant supply of quality food and drinks. It’s a level of generosity and hospitality you rarely encounter. These are the kinds of touches that guests remember and that bring them back. Monika clearly runs this property with pride and integrity. Unlike many businesses that begin with high standards but gradually cut corners, she has remained committed to doing things the right way. It shows in every aspect of the experience—from the condition of the accommodations to the overall atmosphere of care and comfort. A special note for those considering when to visit: winter in the Hamptons is a hidden gem. While it may be chilly, the beauty and tranquility of the area remain, and you have the added benefit of enjoying a luxurious stay."

"We had an amazing weekend staying here with a group of 12 friends. From the moment we arrived, everything exceeded our expectations.The house was spotless and exactly as described in the listing. Everything appeared brand new. There was more than enough room for everyone to sleep comfortably, hang out together, and still have personal space when needed. I especially loved the large dining table.we all ate together.. Our host was fantastic — responsive, helpful, and very clear with instructions, which made check-in and check-out seamless.Overall, this was the perfect place for a friends’ getaway. We’d absolutely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone planning a group trip!"

"Everything was excellent. Rooms were upgraded and were lovely, everything sparkling clean, staff most helpful. The breakfast was great. Would recommend and would stay again. "

"This house has it all. The home is big and has a lot of rooms. There is a great basement to have fun and even workout. The place is fantastic. We will definitely try and stay again. Adam was a gracious host and very responsive. Would recommend to families with kids of all ages. The home worked out perfectly for us!! "

"Very Nice Holiday Home….for a Winter Extended Family Getaway (must be amazing during the summertime)A Hidden gem in the Hamptons, never have to leave!Well appointed decor yet very comfortable and cozyWould recommend highly….."